THE SAME MISTAKES
Eleven months after the death of
his uncle, things are not going well for Toby Anderson. His girlfriend has
disappeared, his parents are fighting and a clingy girl follows him home on the
last day of school, desperate for his attention.
As a series of robberies rock the
community of Kings Beach, Mums sudden departure for Lighthouse Bay triggers a
wave of bizarre happenings that throw the Anderson household into chaos. Unable
to shake the sense that the events of last summer are going to repeat
themselves, Toby encounters a frightening adversary, a haunting force that will
test just how far he will go for those he loves.
In Store Price: $23.00
Online Price: $22.00
Ebook version –
Number of pages: 178
Cover: Clive Dalkins
Publisher: Poseidon Books
Date Published: 2014
Dan Murphy grew up in Happy Valley,
South Australia. At present, he is studying a Graduate
Certificate in Editing and Publishing and working casual hours as a relief
By the same author
– part sample
It was raining. The
source of the thick drops commanded the sky, spreading an awful grey aura onto
the beach. The sand was no longer a fresh golden colour but instead, a dull
green. White-washed waves crashed down violently along the shoreline. A light
breeze attached itself to the raindrops and coaxed the shrubbery and trees
lining the dunes into a flowing dance. Nearby, at house number twenty-six of
Moonlight Avenue, four furry legs trundled across the front lawn where the brick
fence met the ground. There were strange smells left on the bricks and Scooter
was determined to decipher their origin and reclaim his territory. The lawn was
freshly mown and weedy clumps of green grass stuck tightly to his paws.
There was movement! A black bird swept past and he was away, chasing hard and
barking loudly. The bird glided around the side of the house as though it was as
close to being eaten by a dog as Toby was to getting out of bed.
Upstairs, he was fast asleep in the front bedroom. It was a mess. Three used
mugs were sitting on his bedside table, each of them plastered with the remains
of gluggy chocolate flavoured milk. Dirty clothes lay strewn about the floor and
a pile of DVDs was teetering on the edge of his coffee table, ready to drop at
the slightest nudge. What little space of carpet that remained was occupied by
Scooters mat. It was in dire need of a good clean.
Toby rolled over, snorting as his nose squeezed against the soft pillow. Then,
very quietly, a grey nose pushed its way through the gap between the door and
the door frame. Two eyes, one of them surrounded by a brown patch, blinked
expectantly. Toby mumbled as two slimy drops of saliva left the edge of his
mouth. Scooter padded into the room and made his way over to the bed. Two paws
appeared on Tobys pillow. At first, Scooter sniffed at Tobys open mouth. It
smelt rather unpleasant; apparently he hadnt brushed his teeth before bed.
Despite this, as a curious and fearless animal, Scooters tongue lashed out at
his friends sleeping face.
Ergh … What … Toby opened one eye, although it only managed to rise
halfway. Scooter? Go away! Its early! he murmured. He pulled a section of his
sheets up to his face to wipe at the slobber.
Scooter sat back on his haunches, waiting. For several moments, Toby lay
silently and listened to the rain hitting the window outside. The weather was
bad. There was no reason to get out of bed. What was the point? Reluctantly, he
pulled both eyes open and peered downwards at his pet.
Scooter! What have you done? he exclaimed, rising onto one elbow. The grass
and weeds that had been collected by Scooters paws lay in a filthy trail
leading from the doorway. Toby had no doubt that this wasnt the worst of it.
Usually, the laundry door was left open during the night for Scooters benefit.
He wouldve travelled across the entrance hall, up the stairs and across the
hall to get to the bedroom and there was no telling where he had gone before
taking the stairs. He mightve decided on a quick tour of the house while he was
Scooter wagged his tail innocently. Toby flopped back onto his pillow moodily,
tearing his eyes from the messy floor and looking at the time on his mobile
phone. It was half past six. For a few moments, he stared at the big blue
numbers, blinking until the zero transformed into a one. It was now or never. He
thought for a few moments, gazing toward the horizontal blinds and listening for
the crack of each new raindrop as it hit the glass.
Toby grabbed the top of his quilt with
both hands and pulled it over his head, twisting to his right and curling into a
comfortable position. Bed was nicer anyway. Scooter continued to explore the
bedroom, devouring an old apple core that had rolled underneath the coffee
table. Despite the rejection from Toby, his tail continued to wag. The swiftly
swinging body part left no object untouched and the unstable pile of DVDs came
crashing noisily to the floor. Scooter froze, turning to look up at the bed in
fear of Tobys wrath. Nothing but silent ignorance. Either that or he had
already drifted off to sleep.
His eyes opened in a flash.
Toby! Get out of bed now!
It was his mums voice, filtering through the wood of his bedroom door as though
it wasnt wooden at all. Was she speaking into a microphone? Had she secretly
set up a speaker in his bedroom? He had been out of the house all day yesterday.
She had had plenty of time to do it. Toby rubbed at his face and glanced around
at the red walls. Stranger things had happened.
Toby! Mum shouted, knocking on the door.
Mum! Im awake! he yelled back, throwing the bedclothes from his body and
rising into a seated position. Then he saw Scooters green trail leading from
his bed to the doorway and remembered waking up in the middle of the night. Had
it been the middle of the night? What was the time now?
Toby! She knocked loudly. Toby! Open the door please!
No! came an instant reply. You have some explaining to do! And some
Toby sighed, pushing the Home button on his phone. Mum! Im late for school!
Why didnt you tell me?
He leapt from the bed and rushed over to the pile of clothes containing his
uniform. Like a dog digging a hole in the garden, clothes flew outwards in all
directions as he searched for his school shorts. Scooter, who had woken due to
the rise in volume, rolled to his left to avoid a sock.
Why is the door … Mum began.
Suddenly, the bedroom door swept open and she appeared, scowling. Then, her face
disappeared behind a pair of Tobys underwear.
… jammed? she finished, voice muffled behind the material.
Amidst Tobys wild search for his shorts, several pairs of underwear, dirty
socks, t-shirts, pants and jumpers had ended up at opposite ends of the room.
Mum had a very unfortunate sense of timing and one particular pair of underwear
had flown right towards the doorway.
Because there was stuff in the way, Toby answered.
Using only the tips of her fingers, Mum pulled the underwear daintily from her
head and dropped it on the floor as though it was a steaming stack of canine
excrement. Im in half a mind to keep you at home today, she said, moulding
her face to look serious.
Really? he asked gleefully. Wouldnt that be a pleasant end to the week?
No! You will go to school, finish your work and come home immediately. Then,
the entire afternoon will be spent cleaning this filthy floor and the trail of
dirt your animal has left throughout the entire house! Its disgusting!
I wont listen to excuses! The dog will have to stay outside from now on.
She was bluffing. Toby knew she would never keep Scooter from the warmth and
comfort of inside living. This was a one-off mistake anyway.
I know you wouldnt do that, Toby said, gathering his uniform into a bundle.
Dont be so sure.
Mum! Hes never had to stay outside. Toby faced his mum defiantly.
In return, she stood firm in front of the open bedroom door. You dont even
look after him anymore, she argued, pointing down at the dog. He was busy
What are you talking about? Toby responded, shaking his head and looking over
at his friend. He looks alright to me.
As though he could understand, Scooter swung his head from his furry legs and
looked up at Toby through his warm brown eyes.
Mum shook her head. You dont take him out. Hes stuck in the house all the
time. No wonder he isnt behaving.
Hes fine, Toby said, moving towards the doorway.
Dont leave this room, Mum said, raising a finger. Im not finished.
I am! Toby snapped. He pushed his way out and headed for the bathroom.
Well talk later! Mum called.
The bathroom door slammed.
He was late but Toby ate slowly. There was something wrong with the milk. It
tasted different. It was like it had been left out of the fridge for hours. And
what was wrong with the Cornflakes? They were lacking their usual crunch. Had
they been misplaced as well? Everything was wrong and things were about to get
Good morning! said Hayley, striding into the kitchen to prepare her own
breakfast. Her hair was tied into a neat ponytail. Was that a new scrunchie? Or
was it a ribbon? Girls accessories were not really Tobys area of expertise. In
fact, everything about teenage girls was far from his area of expertise.
Mm … he replied absently. He watched the rain through the floor to ceiling
windows. It dribbled out of the sky and settled at its final destination amongst
the miserable grey of the outside world. Why did he have to go to school today?
They would probably end up watching a movie. They might clean some desks or
collect old pieces of work left in the art room.
Cheer up! said Hayley brightly. Last day.
Okay then. Hayley filled a bowl with Cornflakes and settled down on the
opposite side of the dining table. You driving? she asked.
Are you … feeling good in any way? she ventured, aiming for a nerve.
No. Toby stared at the bottom of his bowl, pushing the remains of his cereal
around the disgusting milk. He thought back to when he was little. Every
morning, as he munched through a bowl of delicious Wheat Triangles, he would
direct the flow of milk as though the liquid represented oceans. Any bits of
cereal left at the bottom represented islands. He would pretend that darker bits
of wheat were like little boats, cruising happily around the islands without a
care. Today, the bottom of his plate reminded him of vomit.
Whats with the green stuff? Hayley asked.
The trail through the house.
Oh, I thought you meant … Toby pointed at his bowl.
Hayley rolled her eyes. The weeds and stuff from outside!
Yeah, I know. It was Scooter.
Hayley chuckled, Maybe you were sleep walking last night.
Toby shook his head. Why did his sister only seem to talk to him at breakfast
time? Why did she talk to him at all?
Funny, he replied, standing and taking his bowl into the kitchen to scrape the
remains into the bin. He wasnt very hungry.
He left the room and went upstairs to pack his bag.
Toby made his way slowly towards the school gates, staring nonchalantly at his
mobile screen. It had been a long day. Why was it that the last day was always
the longest? The final bell had sent the younger students into raptures. Excited
screams could be heard as they made their way out of their respective
classrooms, sprinting for freedom, only to be on the receiving end of shouts as
they chose the front seat of the car when it wasnt their turn. Was it freedom?
The summer holidays had arrived. The rain had ceased and the sun was making
every attempt to squeeze past a particularly thick cloud. Toby knew that he
should be feeling good. No more assignments. No more six-hour days spent feeding
on useless information. No more teachers. It sounded amazing. Normally, Toby
would be smiling all the way back to his house in Moonlight Avenue, daydreaming
about a wonderful summer break. But this wasnt normal.
Woah! Toby crashed phone-first into a backpack.
He had walked straight into the back of a year nine girl with messy brown hair.
She turned and stared angrily at his indifferent expression. Why dont you
watch where youre going? she inquired.
A lengthy sigh issued from Tobys mouth. Im sorry. I wasnt watching, he
responded, speaking as though it was the most boring moment of his life. His
gaze returned to his phone and he pushed her aside like a stranger in a crowded
street, continuing in the same direction. For a moment, she stood in shock.
Then, curiously, she followed his trail. Toby had barely made it to the front
gates when he heard a voice coming from behind him.
I know you.
He sighed again.
Youre Toby, right? Toby Anderson?
Why are you talking to me? he asked without turning around, reluctantly
putting his phone into his pocket. Then, he suddenly stopped in his tracks and
the roles were reversed. The girl bumped into Toby and sent him lunging towards
the front gate. Clumsily, he reached out and steadied himself.
The girl burst out, Why did you stop walking? Are you okay? She approached him
and laid one hand on his shoulder.
Why were you walking so close to me? he snapped, looking crossly at her round
Im just trying to be nice to you and all youve done is ask me questions.
What do you … Toby stopped.
Another question. He hesitated. The girl smiled pleasantly. He had to say
something or he would be stuck with her all the way home. I cant have my phone
in my left pocket. It has to be in my right pocket.
The girl giggled. Toby watched her and almost managed a smile.
So what? she said.
You asked why I stopped walking.
Toby nodded, eyebrows raised.
Lets go! she said suddenly, jumping over the fence and walking off down the
What do you mean lets go? Toby asked hurriedly. He just wanted to be alone.
He wanted to be home, sitting on his bed watching television with a mug of
chocolate milk in both hands.
Im walking with you, she said, smiling once again.
She was annoying but there was something about that smile. Toby couldnt quite
discern what it was that he liked about it. Maybe he just liked any smile.
Hopefully he just liked any smile.
No youre not.
Ooh I think I am! she sang, stumbling stupidly over a pebble as she walked
Toby looked around. There were a couple of students taking time to say goodbye
to each other over in the playground. Just outside the main doors a few parents
were speaking with the Principal. Gradually, it was getting quiet and the rush
of excited juniors had disappeared. Kings Beach Area School was emptying,
preparing for a dormant summer. Still, Toby felt terrible. He let go of the
gates and followed her. At least, he walked in the direction of his house. She
was simply walking in his way.
My names Ashlea.
And youre Toby.
Youve already told me that.
You dont talk much.
No. I just dont talk to you.
No response. Rudely, Toby pulled his mobile from his pocket and entered his text
message inbox, trying to find an excuse to ignore Ashlea. At least if he stared
at the phone he wouldnt see her smile.
Its okay. I can talk for the both of us.
Toby couldnt help but look at her after that comment. He made his best attempt
to make her seem small and stupid, frowning at her like she had just eaten her
house keys. Talk for the both of us? he asked, shaking his head in disbelief.
Yeah. Ill say something and make up your response.